| Arsenal 1 to 5 Show / Hide |
| 4 Carlos Vela |
| Blackburn Rovers 6 to 8 Show / Hide |
| 7 Martin Olsson, 8 Vincenzo Grella |
| Bolton Wanderers 9 to 9 Show / Hide |
| 9 Ebi Smolarek |
| Chelsea 10 to 12 Show / Hide |
| 10 Alex, 11 Branislav Ivanovic, 12 Franco Di Santo |
| Everton 13 to 16 Show / Hide |
| 14 Dan Gosling, 15 Segundo Castillo, 16 Victor Anichebe |
| Fulham 17 to 17 Show / Hide |
| 17 Dickson Etuhu |
| Hull City 18 to 19 Show / Hide |
| 19 Daniel Cousin |
| Liverpool 20 to 24 Show / Hide |
| 21 Emiliano Insua, 22 Albert Riera, 23 Nabil El Zhar, 24 David Ngog |
| Manchester City 25 to 27 Show / Hide |
| 25 Ched Evans, 27 Daniel Sturridge |
| Manchester United 28 to 30 Show / Hide |
| 28 Jonny Evans, 29 Rafael, 30 Ji-Sung Park |
| Middlesbrough 31 to 31 Show / Hide |
| 31 Chris Riggott |
| Newcastle United 32 to 33 Show / Hide |
| 33 Shola Ameobi |
| Portsmouth 34 to 39 Show / Hide |
| 35 Noe Pamarot, 36 Armand Traore |
| Stoke City 40 to 41 Show / Hide |
| 41 Michael Tonge |
| Sunderland 42 to 44 Show / Hide |
| 43 Anton Ferdinand |
| Tottenham Hotspur 45 to 46 Show / Hide |
| 45 Vedran Corluka, 46 Fraizer Campbell |
| West Bromwich Albion 47 to 50 Show / Hide |
| 48 Jonas Olsson, 49 Iglesias Borja Valero, 50 Luke Moore |
| West Ham United 51 to 55 Show / Hide |
| 52 Herita Ilunga, 53 Jack Collison, 55 David Di Michele |
| New Signings 56 to 92 Show / Hide |
| 56 Andrey Arshavin, 61 Jo, 66 Wayne Bridge, 71 Ryan Taylor, 76 Angelos Basinas, 67 Nigel De Jong, 77 Matthew Etherington, 68 Craig Bellamy, 73 Peter Lovenkrands, 78 Henri Camara, 59 Ariza Makukula, 64 Alberto Manucho, 69 Zoran Tosic, 74 Hayden Mullins, 65 Shay Given, 75 Jermaine Pennant, 80 Carlo Cudicini |
| Club Captains 93 to 112 Show / Hide |
| 99 Danny Murphy, 102 Richard Dunne, 105 Michael Owen, 108 Dean Whitehead, 100 Ian Ashbee, 103 Gary Neville, 106 Sol Campbell, 98 Phil Neville, 101 Steven Gerrard, 107 Andy Griffin |
| Fans Favourites 113 to 132 Show / Hide |
| 120 Deiberson Geovanni |
| Man of the Match 133 to 152 Show / Hide |
|
| Hat-Trick Heroes 153 to 156 Show / Hide |
|
| Hundred Club 157 to 157 Show / Hide |
|